Partnering with a top third-party logistics (3PL) provider helps your ecommerce business scale efficiently while streamlining fulfillment. But with so many options, how do you choose the best fit?
Red Stag Fulfillment and SHIPHYPE are two of the best 3PLs available, each offering unique advantages. The right choice depends on your business priorities—do you need a specialist in complex, high-value products? Or a provider supporting diverse, multichannel operations?
We’ll compare Red Stag and SHIPHYPE side by side, explore key features, and highlight what sets each apart to help you make an informed decision.
Side-by-side comparison of Red Stag Fulfillment and SHIPHYPE
Red Stag and SHIPHYPE each cater to specific ecommerce needs. The right choice between these 3PLs depends on your business requirements, such as order accuracy, product complexity, or scalability.
| Key Features | Red Stag Fulfillment | SHIPHYPE |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | Custom quote based on each client’s unique business needs | Standard pricing starts at $999/month, custom pricing available for high-volume shippers |
| Core services | Omnichannel fulfillment for ecommerce brands (DTC and B2B), Amazon fulfillment (FBM, SFP, FBA prep) | DTC and B2B fulfillment, FBA prep services |
| Kitting and assembly | Optimized custom kitting services with light assembly, including subscription boxes | Full kitting services with unlimited options and no minimum order requirement |
| Inventory planning | Online dashboard with real-time inventory updates and inventory planning support from Red Stag’s experts | Warehouse Management System for tracking inventory levels, providing real-time updates, and managing stock movement |
| Specializations | Specialized handling for large/bulky and high-value items | Duty-free shipping from Canada to the U.S., crowdfunding, and subscription box fulfillment |
| Shrinkage guarantees | Zero-shrinkage policy that covers the wholesale price if items are damaged or lost | No stated shrinkage guarantees |
| Shipment on-time guarantees | Orders are shipped on time, every time, or Red Stag pays $50 for every late parcel (Same-day shipping, 5PM cutoff available) | All orders placed before cutoff times go out the same day (2 p.m. cutoff time for DTC orders) |
| Receiving time | Guaranteed 2-day receiving | 1-3 business days to process received shipments |
| Integrations | Integrations with all major platforms and marketplaces, including Shopify, Amazon, TikTok, and many more | Integrations with all major platforms and marketplaces, including Shopify, Amazon, TikTok, and many more |
| Fulfillment networks | Two U.S. warehouses (Salt Lake City, UT and Knoxville, TN) | Three Canada warehouses (Toronto and Vancouver), two U.S. warehouses (Los Angeles and New Jersey) |
| Customer support | 24/7 customer support and dedicated account managers | 24/7 customer support and dedicated account managers for larger clients |
Red Stag Fulfillment’s strengths to consider
Red Stag’s fulfillment services help ecommerce businesses efficiently manage inventory, ship orders quickly and accurately, and improve customer satisfaction. Let’s dive into how this support works and what kind of expertise this 3PL offers.
Our expertise
Red Stag excels at managing large, bulky, and high-value items with precision. These products demand careful handling to prevent damage during transit so they reach customers’ homes safely. Our expertise and carrier partnerships also help reduce shipping costs for oversized or heavy items.
One challenge of selling bulky or large products is securing adequate warehouse space for storage. Red Stag’s warehouses are specifically designed to accommodate these items with:
Wide aisles and high ceilings for safe storage and easy maneuverability.
Specialized PIT equipment to move products carefully and efficiently.
Pack lines designed for shipping bulky or heavy items.
Whether you’re selling large items through Amazon FBA, Seller Fulfilled Prime, or multiple channels, Red Stag has the infrastructure to support your needs.
We’re committed to operational excellence and back our services with:
Two-day receiving to keep inventory moving.
Zero shrinkage, covering the wholesale cost of any lost or damaged items.
On-time shipping for every order.
100% order accuracy, ensuring customers receive exactly what they ordered.
These guarantees help businesses fulfill orders efficiently, improve customer satisfaction, and drive repeat sales.
How we support you
As your business grows, managing higher order volumes—especially for high-value or heavy/bulky items—can become challenging. With Red Stag as your 3PL partner, you don’t have to sacrifice quality for scalability. Our fulfillment process is designed to maintain accuracy and efficiency, no matter your growth stage.
We take proactive steps to minimize errors and streamline fulfillment operations, from receiving inventory and restocking to handling returns.
Note: We guarantee order accuracy, and if a mistake occurs, we pay you $50 and cover shipping costs to correct it.
Our customer support team provides clear, reliable communication. We also offer a ticket-based system for 24/7 assistance, along with phone support during standard business hours, Monday through Friday.
Reach out to us to learn more about our guarantees, services, and support.
SHIPHYPE’s strengths to consider
SHIPHYPE provides fulfillment services aimed at helping ecommerce businesses scale across multiple channels. Their offerings include DTC and B2B fulfillment for small businesses and medium-sized businesses, Amazon fulfillment, and Section 321 duty-free shipping from Canada to the U.S.
Their expertise
SHIPHYPE offers flexibility for businesses building diverse operational strategies. They support Amazon fulfillment models, including Amazon FBA and FBM, with expertise in FBA prep services such as labeling, custom packaging, and bundling to meet Amazon’s strict requirements.
Their fulfillment services also include carton and pallet forwarding, as well as private label shipping across the U.S., Canada, and international markets, helping brands expand their reach.
SHIPHYPE’s scalable solutions adapt to growing order volumes, supporting omnichannel fulfillment across various sales channels, from brick-and-mortar stores to online marketplaces.
How they support you
Managing shipping costs and transit times can be challenging, especially with a broad customer base. SHIPHYPE has fulfillment centers on both coasts in the U.S. and Canada, making it easier to offer shipping services that reduce transit times and shipping rates. They also have plans to expand with additional warehouse locations in the U.S. and internationally, including Australia, China, the U.K., and the U.A.E.
For businesses experiencing rapid growth, SHIPHYPE processes large order volumes with a focus on efficiency and quality to help you maintain customer satisfaction. However, while they take steps to provide accurate, on-time shipping, they don’t offer guarantees.
Considerations when choosing SHIPHYPE include:
Expertise: They specialize in handling high order volumes, but they don’t focus on fragile, high-value, or large/bulky items.
Customer support: Options include 24/7 support via phone, live chat, and email, with dedicated account management for larger clients.
How to decide between Red Stag Fulfillment and SHIPHYPE
Choosing the right 3PL provider is critical to your company’s success. If you’re deciding between Red Stag and SHIPHYPE, consider key factors like specialized package handling, scalability, and omnichannel fulfillment to determine the best path for your business.
Identify your product needs
What do your products require for proper packing and shipping? The answer depends on what you sell. Large or bulky items, like furniture or large-screen TVs, need careful handling for storage, packing, and shipping. High-value items, such as fragile electronics, also require specialized care to avoid damage in transit.
If your product requires specialized handling, consider choosing Red Stag for its expertise in managing large/bulky, fragile, and high-value items. Our advanced storage, careful packing, and shipping processes help prevent damage, making sure products reach customers safely and as expected.
For businesses prioritizing high-volume fulfillment and omnichannel support, both Red Stag and SHIPHYPE offer scalable solutions. Red Stag pairs high order accuracy guarantees with specialized handling, making it ideal for large or high-value products at scale. SHIPHYPE offers extensive multichannel integrations and a fulfillment network across the U.S. and Canada, making it a solid option for businesses expanding across marketplaces.
If you sell subscription boxes or multi-item kits, Red Stag offers optimized kitting services for businesses needing light assembly, custom packaging, or bundling of large or high-value products. If you need unlimited kitting options without order minimums, SHIPHYPE provides broader kitting flexibility for various product types.
Evaluate operational conditions
Whether your business scales rapidly or experiences steady growth, choosing a 3PL that can expand with you—without compromising quality—matters. This helps you keep customers satisfied, encourage repeat business, and strengthen your brand reputation.
Assessing growth potential is just one factor to consider. You’ll also need to evaluate seasonal fluctuations and order volumes to determine which service provider offers the right features and support.
To make these assessments:
Calculate your average monthly order volume.
Compare current order volume with past periods to identify trends, such as seasonal sales spikes.
Analyze month-by-month data to track fluctuations.
Consider your market size and industry trends to gauge growth potential.
Review revenue growth over the past few years to understand your trajectory.
Knowing these factors can help you choose a fulfillment company that supports your scalability needs.
Consider accuracy and guarantees
Customers expect their orders to arrive on time and in perfect condition. Delays, missing items, or damaged products can lead to dissatisfaction, hurting your brand reputation and making it harder to retain or attract customers.
Choosing an ecommerce fulfillment provider with on-time delivery and accuracy guarantees enhances your brand’s reliability. When customers know they can trust you to deliver the right products quickly, they’re more likely to buy again.
Red Stag stands behind its guarantees:
Fast shipping, including same-day fulfillment for orders received before the cutoff.
100% order accuracy to prevent incorrect or missing products.
Two-day receiving to maintain inventory flow.
Zero shrinkage, covering the wholesale cost of lost or damaged items.
Think about your business requirements
Understanding your business needs is critical to choosing the right 3PL partner. Consider the following factors:
| Business Requirement | Best Fulfillment Partner and Why |
|---|---|
| Do you ship large, bulky, or fragile items like musical instruments, home appliances, or pool products? | Red Stag specializes in handling bulky and delicate products with care. |
| Is guaranteed accuracy a must, especially for high-value or large items that aren’t easily replaced? | Red Stag provides a 100% accuracy guarantee—if mistakes happen, we cover the cost. |
| Does your business need FBA prep services? | SHIPHYPE offers standalone FBA prep services. (Red Stag will perform FBA prep as part of a larger omnichannel operation.) |
Find the right 3PL partner for you
A reliable 3PL provider helps your business scale while maintaining efficiency, accuracy, and a positive customer experience. Whether you need specialized handling for large or high-value products, guaranteed order accuracy, or seamless omnichannel support, choosing the right partner is key to long-term success.
Red Stag offers secure, scalable fulfillment solutions designed to support growing ecommerce businesses. Our guarantees, expert handling, and commitment to operational excellence help streamline logistics and build lasting customer relationships.
Want to learn more about how Red Stag can support your fulfillment needs? Get in touch with us today.
